The us has executed military engagements since vietnam, particularly the first persian gulf war and the war in afghanistan, that offer more accurate points of comparison. Thus, it is important to analyse the differences between iraqi war and afghanistan war veterans and persian gulf and vietnam war veterans in terms of ptsd diagnosis as iraqi war and afghan war veterans, persian gulf and vietnam war veterans alike make claims for veterans affairs (va) disability compensation for disability benefits, an analysis . War in afghanistan vs vietnam war vietnam before us involvement japanese oust french government that was previously in place and placed bao dai as their ruler after wwii, vietnam, laos, and cambodia were returned to french control and ho chi minh proclaimed a temporary government september of 1945 .
But the difference between today and even vietnam, not to mention world war ii, is stark in iraq and afghanistan, there was one death for every 378 service members who deployed in vietnam, the figure was one death for every 58 who deployed, and in both world war i and world war ii it was around one per 40. The war in afghanistan is the period in which the united states invaded the country after the september 11 attacks, supported initially by close allies, and eventually by the wider north atlantic . The vietnam war and the iraq war were fought for different reasons, which makes any comparison moot vietnam was fought to stop the spread of communism and to try to keep south vietnam free the iraq war is being fought for the freedom of the usa and to stop terrorism.
America’s top critics are unanimous in their praise for the vietnam war fellow warriors: iraq, afghanistan, vietnam john musgrave is a marine veteran who counsels active-duty soldiers and veterans. Afghanistan afghanistan vs vietnam if the us retreats with a bloody nose, the consequences for the world would be too dreadful to contemplate if the vietnam war was purely a civil war, or a . The afghan war has lasted longer than vietnam, but the 2,408 american deaths in afghanistan are 41 percent of vietnam’s total and every american fighting there is a volunteer.
The vietnam war was a long, costly war and its impact will be felt for years it was a war between the communist region of north vietnam with its southern allies, the viet cong, and south vietnam with its main ally, the united states. Soviet afghanistan vs us vietnam well the vietnam war wasnt really a declared war but the us sent troops anyways to stop communism from spreading to . Vietnam, synonymous with quagmire, is shorthand for an unwinnable war so it was over the war in iraq and so it is now over the one in afghanistan. I have to evaluate whether or not the afghanistan war is like the vietnam war can anyone help. Both the soviets and the americans chose to withdraw their troops from vietnam and afghanistan the vietnam war was seen as a failure by the americans and the soviet invasion marked the beginning of a disintegrating soviet union.
The iraq war, as heather marie stur tells us , should not be lumped together with the vietnam war as blindly and repeatedly as many seem wont to do although the two military expeditions both rank . Vietnam vs us war movies best full movie: the legend makers | english subtitles subscribe: the legend makers is such an emotional m. One fought against soviet occupation in afghanistan, the mujahideen, while the other, the viet cong, the communist organization in vietnam, waged war against us and other nato forces both civilian populations played a part in accepting or covertly disrupting operations. The vietnam conflict extract data file of the defense casualty analysis system (dcas) extract files contains records of 58,220 us military fatal casualties of the vietnam war these records were transferred into the custody of the national archives and records administration in 2008.
By that definition, vietnam was indeed a war however, since the united states congress never declared war against vietnam, it was actually a conflict in fact, the us congress hasn’t declared any war since the world war ii in 1942. Afghanistan is similar to vietnam based on my research i believe that the afghanistan war and the vietnam war are similar first of all, in both wars the enemies defeated a european power, then ended up in a civil war for national reunification. The war on terrorism has produced casualties in iraq, afghanistan, africa, syria, and other middle eastern countries during the vietnam war (1964 to 1975), there . Vietnam war (1964-1975) total us servicemembers (worldwide) 8,744,000 7 3,403,000 battle deaths 47,434 veterans who served in iraq and afghanistan 11 .
Comparing and contrasting the vietnam war vs the on going afghanistan war. The top one percent, war profiteers, who are profiting from the war in afghanistan, are the enemies they are the ones destroying democracy vietnam war: in the . The specter of vietnam haunts the ongoing debate about whether there should be more or less united states engagement in afghanistan but exactly which vietnam is doing the haunting depends on whom you read for gail sheehy, the afghanistan war resembles the one in vietnam that, sheehy says, she and .